The summer is coming to an end and the school planning has begun in earnest! Everyone is talking about books, myself included. My mentoring sessions have increased as usual for this time of year and I find myself living vicariously through those who have these sweet 1st and 2nd grade years to plan…and all the way up to 12th grade!
There is something that, as the years go by, I find myself repeating over and over to others. And that is this; I would much rather see families choose fewer books and live with them properly than an entire list from any curriculum that results in box-checking for having read the book.*
I occasionally share my schedules with those I mentor. That feels safe to me because I can qualify why I do what I do with the philosophical foundations intact. Inevitability, the person looking at is is rather stunned. Why? Because it appears to be a much lighter load than they were anticipating. Yet some have mentioned that my children are the best-read people they know. Indeed, Mason states that “A child of any age should be a well-read person for his age.” (from The Story of Charlotte Mason, p. 116) So how do those two things exist at the same time – well-read children and a lighter schedule? I think it has to do with how those books are used.
In order for me to properly introduce a book to my child (scaffolding), attentively listen to narrations (administrating), appropriately engage in fruitful discussions (grand conversationing), I need to choose fewer excellent books. My brain simply doesn’t have the time, knowledge, or energy to properly engage with dozens of titles every single day. The result of assigning too many books is either burnout or box checking.
“You mean occasionally people have a problem with this even in a Mason paradigm?”
No, I mean people often have a problem with this in a Mason paradigm.
And just to emphasize my point, in the April 1909 L’Umile Pianta we read this:
“Miss Mason intends the programme to fit the child, and not, as some wildly imagine, the child to fit the programme.”
So when I planned my school years, I would write up an ambitious and glorious rough draft of the books and things I think would be great for that child that year. Then slowly, over the course a a few days, I pared things down, down, down, until the schedule breathes and flows with … life. Try it. You’ll know when you have it right for your family as there will most likely be peace in your heart.
Warmly,
Nancy
*I recognize that yes, sometimes you can use huge book lists with certain children. (I had some of those.) And yes, sometimes you should use about 1/2 of those lists with certain children. (I has some of those, too.) It’s about how those books are used and the relationships that should ensue in the end.
Your thoughts?